For five years, The Share Trust has been working to shift power and funding to local actors. Through research, advocacy, and collaboration, we have gathered practical insights into what it takes to move from intention to implementation. Our series, 5 years, 5 Actions, from Learning to Practice, brings those lessons together, outlining five clear pathways for donors, INGOs, and global institutions to contribute to building more equitable, locally led systems.
Action 4: International Intermediaries Can Advance Locally Led Action With Attention and Intention
Over the last decade, many donors have made high-level collective or individual commitments to advance locally led development and humanitarian assistance: the Grand Bargain, the Donor Statement on Locally Led Development, and PEPFAR’s local funding targets, to name a few. Many of these have centered, in large part, on the goal of increasing funding to local actors. This is an important aspiration (as we discussed in our 5 Years, 5 Actions piece on local intermediaries), and limited progress toward it suggests it remains as important as ever.
But focusing primarily on local funding misses the bigger picture. Our engagements with local and international actors repeatedly point to the same conclusion: what makes a response locally led is not principally who holds the contract or grant, but who holds decision making power. It also happens that local decision making matters for results, too. Research, including a meta-analysis of USAID’s entire evaluation library and The Share Trust’s own study on local agency in humanitarian programs, links local decision making to more effective projects.
When local funding is the main lens of localization success, however, this not only glosses over the importance of whether local awards come with local agency, it also misses the opportunity to structure international partnerships—which still make up the vast majority of development and humanitarian assistance—intentionally around local leadership and decision making.
While local partnerships should be a first choice, they won’t always be the right choice for a given donor or project. Legal and policy restrictions can limit the types of partners donors fund; management burden—and shrinking donor staff rolls—favor fewer, larger awards; and urgent needs demand speed and scale. Local also doesn’t automatically mean inclusive; where certain groups are not well represented by local organizations that a donor can fund directly (which are often those that are relatively large, formal, and interested in donor funding), reaching diverse groups may require a broader range of partners.
International partners also bring certain comparative advantages. While each organization has its own strengths (and challenges), as a broad category, international intermediaries can do things like: absorb significant donor funding; work at scale; prefinance activities; access and maintain global supply chains; be neutral, impartial, and independent in contested or conflict affected areas; negotiate with donors, aided by shared language and culture; provide duty of care to downstream partners; and utilize global banking arrangements. UN agencies, in particular, bring strengths in convening, standard setting, and engaging governments, while INGOs—which tend to be more transparent than UN agencies—can be particularly well placed to manage donor compliance, support networks and learning across countries, and facilitate fundraising and advocacy in the Global North.
International intermediaries are, however, sometimes viewed as holding onto power and stymieing progress on locally led action. This can be a very real dynamic. But international intermediaries are also a highly diverse group. And as our research on intermediary models for locally led action shows, many can and do play a significant role in shifting resources and decision-making power to local actors when there is intention—both on the part of the intermediary and their donors—around those goals. For example, international intermediaries can—and should:
- Elevate local decision making, for example by creating majority local governance boards, ensuring local partners have leadership roles in consortia, co-creating project design and implementation with local partners and communities, and using local/peer nomination for funding allocation decisions;
- Emphasize accountability to local actors, for example by building in local accountability and feedback mechanisms with affected populations and adapting programming accordingly, as well as soliciting and acting upon feedback from local downstream partners on partnership quality;
- Share risk with local partners, for example by jointly identifying risks and co-creating risk mitigation plans;
- Share resources fairly, including ensuring fair passthrough of overhead costs to local downstream partners to support their organizational health and well-being;
- Transition responsibility to local actors throughout the course of a program or partnership or focus on back-end support, deferring to local downstream partners to lead on substance;
- Raise local partners’ visibility in branding, communications, and engagement with donors;
- Create internal incentives to advance locally led action, for example, through senior leadership commitment, internal policies with accountability for their implementation, and the inclusion of localization priorities in staff job descriptions and performance criteria.
We find that the international intermediaries most successful in these roles often either have locally led action built into their core operating model as a feature that donors “buy into” (locally led pooled funds, for example) or they receive clear direction from donors, specified in award terms and reaffirmed through accountability processes, that devolving resources and decision-making power or transitioning responsibility is a core requirement of the work. Too often, however, donors don’t provide that direction. In our research, international intermediaries repeatedly highlighted that donors don’t evaluate prospective partners on their ability to elevate local leadership. Nor do they ask for processes that can support locally led action in scopes of work or terms of reference—or consistently include budget for these processes, even though they take time and resources to do well. Moreover, accountability focuses more often on policy and fiduciary compliance, sectoral indicators and, in some cases, money passed on to local actors rather than on participatory and equitable partnerships.
While international intermediaries can make some of their own choices to support locally led action, as described above, donors have a critical role, too.
Our call to action for them is to:
For competitive international awards, build a focus on local leadership processes into scopes of work, including criteria around governance structures, co-creation, local accountability and feedback loops, and other participatory processes. Where possible, structure scopes of work around supporting local actors to deliver rather than direct delivery.
Select international partners on the basis of local leadership qualifications, in addition to technical and cost criteria. A partner evaluation lens could include how well a partner and proposed key personnel elevate local actors in governance structures, create meaningful local feedback loops, pass on flexibilities to local actors, and engage local partners and communities in co-creation. Our Decision Framework on Intermediary Partner Selection for Locally Led Action shows how this can work across a range of partners. While it starts with local partners as a default choice, it then walks donors through the factors to weigh, and in what order, when an international partner is the better fit.
Create timelines and budgets for processes that support local leadership, like co-creation, locally led capacity strengthening, joint risk identification and mitigation, and the creation of local feedback loops. Requiring and budgeting for fair passthrough of indirect costs to local partners is also critical.
Emphasize locally led and participatory approaches in accountability processes with partners. Donors should require monitoring, evaluation and learning frameworks to focus on measured levels of local decision making (for instance, using tools such as The Share Trust’s Local Agency and Effectiveness Compass or King’s College London’s Decision Mapping Tool), the quality of local partnerships, and the quality and regularity of co-creation processes, among other factors. Check-ins with partners should ask about how local feedback informs project adaptation.
Focus on transitioning responsibilities to local actors as a goal from the outset. Donors and intermediaries should include progress toward these transitions as core milestones and deliverables.



